Explaining the gap: the UK steps back from mandatory climate reporting

November 3, 2026

Akshithaa Sellvarajah

What’s happening? The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has finalised rules requiring listed companies to report against the UK Sustainability Reporting Standards (UK SRS) on a comply-or-explain basis. The rules replace existing climate-reporting requirements for listed companies with standards aligned to the UK-endorsed International Sustainability Standards Board framework. The regulator said the approach supports global consistency and comparability, while giving companies room to explain how their circumstances shape their disclosures. Companies can use transitional reliefs of one year for Scope 3 emissions disclosures and two years for wider sustainability disclosures. (FCA)

‍

Why does this matter?  The decision lands at an awkward moment for climate disclosure. Large companies are becoming quieter about sustainability, while investors increasingly view climate as a factor in asset pricing. A regime that lets companies choose between reporting and explaining puts more weight on how the market reads those explanations.

‍

A softer landing – The FCA changed course after feedback about the disproportionate burden mandatory climate disclosures could place on smaller listed companies, UK competitiveness concerns and the complexity of a mixed regime. Climate reporting itself remains in place. Linklaters noted that the FCA’s existing Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures-aligned regime was introduced to the Listing Rules in 2020, and that disclosures or explanations, including on Scope 3, must still appear in annual reports. In practice, the UK has upgraded the standard while keeping the enforcement model. The FCA is consulting on a Technical Note to help companies apply comply-or-explain proportionately. Supporters will see proportionality, while critics are likely to see a missed chance to make climate data comparable across the market.

‍

Reporting quietly – Corporate behaviour suggests the work is continuing with less fanfare. Advisory firm Teneo analysed 250 sustainability reports from S&P 500 companies and found that 87% of those that published last year did so again in 2026, yet only 32% issued a press release alongside it, down from 62% in 2022. Just 4% of reports carried “ESG” in the title, compared with 35% in 2022. However, 75% obtained external assurance for their data, up from 54% in 2022. The less comfortable finding is that disclosure of workforce demographic data fell from 92% to 64% YoY. While is a US sample, it shows that disclosures without a firm mandate behind them can disappear quickly once scrutiny rises.

‍

Investors still asking – Investor demand is heading in the opposite direction. A Robeco survey found that more than eight in ten investors expect physical climate risks to affect asset prices over the next decade, and that climate has risen as an investor priority for the first time since political backlash gathered pace in 2023. The shift is modest, with 47% of respondents saying climate is significant or central to their investment policy, up from 46%. Even so, investors pricing physical risk need consistent data to do it.

‍

Looking forward – Comply-or-explain is only as strong as the scrutiny an explanation receives, which makes the FCA’s Technical Note more important than it first appears. If explanations become boilerplate, comparability will suffer. Nevertheless, there is a lateral reading. In a market where most investors expect climate risk to show up in asset prices, choosing to “explain” becomes a disclosure in its own right. Capital markets may end up enforcing what the rules no longer require, and the cost of staying silent could prove higher than the cost of reporting.

Other

Articles you might like

Go to blog